Sunday, October 24, 2010

Parlez-vous français?

Last week, I wrote about how walking can protect your brain against cognitive decline. Sounds easy, right? The truth is, there are several factors that impact brain health, and exercise is just one of them. This week, I'm going way back in time to 2007 to look at a different way to keep your brain healthy: apprendre une autre langue.

Canadian researchers were interested in the relationship between bilingualism and Alzheimer's disease. Their hypothesis was based on the concept of cognitive reserve, a term that represents the attributes of your brain that make it resistant to damage. For example, you might have heard that keeping your mind challenged by doing crossword puzzles can delay cognitive decline. This is one way to increase your cognitive reserve. Presumably, complex mental activity like crossword puzzles but also like speaking more than one language can lead to a lesser chance of developing dementia and, in the event where you do get dementia, a slower rate of decline.

The researchers sifted through the records of over 200 patients from a memory clinic. About half of their sample spoke one language and half spoke two languages. The researchers assessed the relationship between the number of languages each patient spoke and whether each patient had Alzheimer's disease. For the patients who did have Alzheimer's disease, the researchers noted how old the person was when the disease started. Of course, the researchers controlled their results for all the obvious potential biases, such as cultural differences, immigration, formal education and employment status.

The results of this analysis show that the bilingual patients developed Alzheimer's disease much later (4.1 years on average) than the monolingual patients. Since developing an age-associated disease like Alzheimer's later means you have a greater chance of dying before you get the disease, delaying the onset by 4 years means a reduction in the total cases of Alzheimer's disease. Currently, no drugs have an effect that's comparable to bilingualism.

Since no study is ever perfect, let me point out two small caveats before you fish out your old high school Spanish books. First, there is one thing the researchers could not control for, and that is whether cultural differences could lead to delays in seeking medical help for a condition. This could muck up the results because if some patients delayed their first medical visit, then the age at which they received the diagnosis for Alzheimer's disease could be skewed. Second, the protective effect of speaking two languages cannot be generalized to people who have some knowledge of another language but are not fully bilingual. In this study, the patients who were bilingual were true bilinguals, fluent in both languages and having used both languages regularly for most of their lives.

Still, it's a good reminder that a busy mind is a healthy mind. And it's nice to have evidence to justify the occasional weekend in Paris.

Reference: Bilingualism as a protection against the onset of symptoms of dementia. (2007) Bialystok E et al. Neuropsychologia 45:459-464.

3 Responses to “Parlez-vous français?”

Fawn said...

Very interesting! Where did this study take place? Wouldn't it be interesting if this study could be replicated in Europe, where there are plenty of countries where people commonly speak two, three, or four languages?

Anonymous said...

An excellent and delightful analysis, SC. Fawn makes a good point, and BTW is well-protected due to her multi-lingual abilities.

My thoughts drifted to how certain areas have so much specific vernacular that they are sometimes referred to as a 'language'. Such as medicine or computer science. Or am I extrapolating too far from 'jargon'? Barbara

@ Fawn: The study took place in Toronto. The authors do mention a similar study in Australia, but I haven't looked for similar European studies. I'm sure they are out there, though. And I think that the findings could be replicated.

@Barbara: I think that a large knowledge base (like your "medicine" example) can contribute towards your reserve, but in this case it's my understanding that it's not just about having the knowledge, it's about using it. Though I think that some studies show that high education is also somewhat protective, so that goes hand in hand with what you're thinking.

© 2009 Scientific Chick. All Rights Reserved | Powered by Blogger
Design by psdvibe | Bloggerized By LawnyDesignz